A few months ago, I stood with a pint of Guinness in my hand, talking to Sean McCarthy of Steorn. We were in Dublin and he looked at me bemused and said something to the effect, how can you believe us when you’ve seen no evidence? At various times and in so many words he has repeated that sentiment to others. I’ve never liked doing what I was told and I have no intention of starting now. It makes absolute sense to be sceptical of their claims, but there is also a lot of confusion out there stirred, in part, by Steorn's attack on science. With blood boiling , scientists and engineers talk about the scientific method and rage against the company's approach to launching their product. They see it as a perversion of the scientific method, I see it as good marketing. So, to clarify what I believe at this point in time:
Steorn has a machine that can produce free energy. It can be manufactured at reasonable cost. The energy density is useful and the technology has the power to change the world.
Notice that I say nothing about perpetual motion or the Laws of Thermodynamics or Conservation of Energy. The question of where the energy comes from could, when answered, change the world again, but for now these areas confuse the subject. When I say I believe Steorn, I’m not saying that I agree with their conjecture. They are not scientists, they are engineers. They say they have built a machine that could power a Porsche and fit in the engine compartment. You cannot mistake such a thing. There is no room for error. They have either done what they say or they are lying. It was this realisation that formed my frame of reference when trying to figure out the truth of it all.
Motivation
Whatever they’re up to it is costing them money. The expensive advert, the premises in Docklands Park, the staff, the admin, websites, software, marketing and security costs, all constitute serious and ongoing expenditure. SPDC and jury costs are significant and I estimate them to be around one million Euros. Over the past few years they have been funded by private investors to the tune of fourteen million Euros.
The risks they are taking are enormous. As an engineering firm, their credibility is on the line. I have met Sean’s wife, people all around the world know their names and some idiots have even posted his address on the net for all to see. You do not put you and your family on the line like that unless you are deranged, an uncaring and evil trickster, or you are telling the truth.
It’s reasonably safe to say that the motivation behind this is (at least, partially) money. Steorn has a responsibility to investors. When the story broke last year, many people argued that it had to be a scam. Most have moved away from that position now and, for those still unwilling to make the leap across the fence to the believers’ side, many wonder if it is a strange social experiment, a viral campaign for something all together different, or a weird art project where money is no object.
The reason I don’t go along with this is that McCarthy and the other Steorn employees would have to be incredible actors to pull this thing off in the way they have. Their public face is consistent and laudable. It’s not simply that they would have to be a collection of drama-trained engineers, but that they would also have to be incredibly evil to do what they are doing if they were not telling the truth.
Let’s put that statement in context. Steorn has publicly stated that it is building a water pump in Africa as part of a humanitarian drive to help those less fortunate than us. The company has set up the SPDC where over 250 members of the public are investing a lot of their time in the hope that they are working on a project with a strong moral imperative at its core. Many members believe that Steorn has the power, the will and the care to give water to the thirsty, irrigate deserts, desalinate seawater, feed the poor, stop global warming, turn oil nations into nations, shift trillions of dollars from destructive programs to constructive ones, level the playing field for third world countries so that they can jump directly to the 21st century without having to pass through the 20th to get there - and much, much more.
Sometime in July, the company will demo their technology to the public in London. It will run for ten days without external power and, they say, it will demonstrate a working machine based on their claims. Apart from members of the public being able to view the machine in person, millions of people around the world will be able to see it through a web-cam on the net.
These statements are so specific that there is no defence later in saying it was all a joke and that no harm was done. I have personally moved countries to be part of this incredible journey (albeit independently) and there are people planning to fly across the world to see the demo in July.
So, while I, and many others, have very specific reasons and strong circumstantial evidence that they are on the level, my early conversion came down to this:
Do I believe that these people are evil, or do I think they are telling the truth? In November last year, I jumped on a plane to attend a forum party in Dublin. I met the main players in this game and I can tell you that these people are genuine, honest, and know what they are talking about. To me these simple observations have enormous implications and, as I watch McCarthy & Co gear themselves to change the world, I cannot help but wonder at our fortune that it is them and not some Bill Gates wannabe who are driving this juggernaut onto the stage. The magnitude and importance of this statement will become obvious to all in the coming year.
Over the next week, I will draw up a summary of evidence and provide an introduction to Steorn that newcomers can use to bring themselves up to speed. I will make this a separate document that you can access at any time from a link on the right. Before I sign off, however, I should emphasise that the London demo is unlikely to kill the controversy surrounding Steorn’s claims. They will not provide proof or show the blueprint of the design. Many watchers will suspect some sort of trick. The company knows this and continues to emphasise that the only proof that matters is the one that will come from the team of 22 independent scientists who are, right now, examining their technology with complete freedom and with great care. Nevertheless, if this is not some sort of mirage, the demo in London will be a turning point for humanity whether it knows it or not.
Labels: steorn spdc mccarthy energy pmm humanitarian evidence